Better Game Golf
Short answer

Why can I not stop flipping my hands at impact?

Because the flip is a compensation rather than the fault. If your hips thrust towards the ball and you stand up through impact, your arms get trapped behind you, and your hands become the only thing left that can square the face. Being told to stop flipping cannot work while the body position that forces it is still there. You have to give the arms room first.

Answered by , author of The Golfing Bodymind, drawing on the Golfing Bodymind method.

Early extension is the fault. The flip is what it forces

Losing your posture through the strike goes by several names: early extension, standing up through impact, the hips thrusting towards the ball. Whatever you call it, the consequence is mechanical and it is not a matter of willpower. The space your arms needed on the way down is no longer there, so they end up trapped behind you.

From there the hands are the only tool left for squaring the face, and they do the job in the only time available, which is late and fast. That is a flip. It is an intelligent solution to a problem somebody else gave you, which is exactly why instructions to stop doing it have never worked.

Why Sandy treats this as a bodymind fault rather than handing it over

This is the most bodymind fault there is. The position is usually not available to the golfer in the first place, and that is a question about how the body has been used all week rather than about the swing.

Poor posture from a sedentary life leaves muscles shortened and tightened and joints stuck, and that is what turns up at the course. It is the reason a Golfing Bodymind programme carries as much mobility work as it does. You do not fix a position you cannot get into by being told to get into it.

You cannot see it, so measure what it does

Early extension does not show up on a launch monitor as a number called early extension. What shows up is the consequence, and the consequence is specific: your strike scatters both ways across the face, and your woods get caught low.

So measure that. Film it down the line with the phone at hip height, every session, and watch the strike spread come down over weeks. This matters more than it sounds. Golfers who have been working blind for months usually stop because nothing was telling them it was working, not because the drill was wrong.

Why a feel will not do it

The same trap as every other swing change. Your sense of where your own body is rewards the familiar, so the correct position will feel wrong and the old one will keep feeling right. Chasing the feel is how the habit survives.

The way through is the Alexander pair. Inhibition first, stopping the habitual reaction before it fires, then direction, giving the body several directions at once rather than one thing to remember. Then repetition, for thirty to ninety days, because that is how long it takes for a new pattern of use to become the default one.

Understand the mechanism, not the fix

Sandy is insistent about this and it applies past this one fault. A golfer who understands why something works can apply it to the next lie. A golfer who only has the fix is memorising a trick, and a trick does not survive the day it meets a sidehill lie or a tight pin.

So the thing worth taking from this page is not a drill. It is the chain: how you use your body all week decides what position is available, the position decides what the arms can do, and the hands only take over when nothing else can.

Where this comes from

The early extension chain, trapped arms, the flip as compensation, the strike spread and the down the line filming are coaching doctrine from src/lib/prompts/sandy.ts, the prompt Sandy is run on. Posture, shortened muscles and stuck joints are from Chapter 2 of The Golfing Bodymind, Posture is Power, and the daily life zone in Chapter 8. Faulty sensory perception, inhibition and direction are from Chapters 1 and 4.

Sandy Dunlop wrote The Golfing Bodymind in 1980 and has coached golfers at every level since.

Go deeper on this

Related questions

What is early extension in golf?

Losing your posture through impact: the hips thrust towards the ball and you stand up out of the shot. It takes away the room the arms needed on the way down, which traps them behind you and leaves the hands as the only way left to square the face.

How do I know if I have early extension?

You will not see it directly on a launch monitor. Look for the consequences instead: strike scattering both ways across the face and woods caught low. Then film yourself down the line with the phone at hip height so you can watch the pattern rather than guess at it.

Will mobility work fix early extension?

It is where the work usually starts, because a sedentary week leaves muscles shortened and joints stuck, and you cannot hold a position that is not available to you. But the pattern itself still needs inhibition, direction and repetition over thirty to ninety days before it becomes the default.

Next question

Put this into your own game

Answer a few questions and Sandy builds a plan around the rounds you actually play, covering practice, mind, body and food. Free, and no card.