
Because a part of you has taken the whole of you over. Psychosynthesis calls these sub personalities: the Perfectionist, the Critic, the Imposter, the Thinker. Each one has a genuine gift and each one becomes a prison the moment you can no longer tell it apart from yourself. The way back out is one sentence. I am a perfectionist, and I am not my perfectionist.
Answered by Sandy Dunlop, author of The Golfing Bodymind, drawing on the Golfing Bodymind method.
Roberto Assagioli's psychosynthesis is the second of the three systems the Golfing Bodymind is built from, and it starts from an observation anybody can check: you behave quite differently in different parts of your life, and under pressure you meet versions of yourself that surprise you.
Sandy's starting list for golfers is the Perfectionist, the Critic of self and others, the Imposter, the Thinker, the Thunderer, the Iceman, the Fighter, the Excuser, the Talker, the Saboteur, the Victim and the Poser. He names tour players for several of them, because they are easier to see in somebody else first. You will recognise most of them from your own fourball.
This is where the idea is usually mishandled. Every one of these parts has real value. The Perfectionist is the drive to improve, to put the hours in, to go after mastery. The Critic gives honest feedback on performance, and no journey of improvement works without it.
The damage starts when the part becomes punitive and takes the joy out of the game. Shivas Irons, in Michael Murphy's Golf in the Kingdom, gives the warning in five words: beware the quicksands of perfection. The Critic has its own failure mode, sometimes called the top dog, a voice full of shoulds and oughts that cuts to the bone, and it is often an internalised version of somebody who was never satisfied with you.
The core psychosynthesis exercise is small enough to do on the tee. You name the part, out loud or not, and then you add the distancing half. I am a perfectionist, and I am not my perfectionist.
It sounds like word play and it is not. Identification is what gives a part its power: we are dominated by whatever the self becomes identified with, and we can control whatever we dis-identify from. The sentence puts you, as Sandy says, on the balcony, and the balcony is where choices exist. It generalises to anything. I am frightened, and I am not my fear. I am thinking negatively, and I am not my negativity.
Parts also fight each other, which is why some rounds feel incoherent rather than simply bad. The Perfectionist gets in the way of the Fighter. The responsible one gets in the way of the ambitious performer. One part of you stands there growling at another.
Sandy quotes Sun Tzu on this: the battle is won before it is engaged. The battle he means is the internal one. Resolve that and you turn up to the first tee having already settled the thing that was going to beat you.
Take the part that is most in the foreground. Give it a name. Get an image for it, and draw it if you like. Write down how it typically behaves, what it does and where it shows up. Write down its strengths and its gifts, honestly. Then how it traps you and holds you back. Then what it wants and what it needs. Then its relationships with the other parts.
The point is not to defeat it. Sandy sets out four stages past that: recognition, acceptance, coordination between the parts that are at war, and harmony. What you are building is what Shivas Irons called a solid place to swing from, before you open up so wide that you get swept away.
The sub personality list, the positive and negative face of each, the dis-identification sentence, the balcony, the four stages and the written exercise are from Chapter 5 of The Golfing Bodymind, Personality: One or Many. The Shivas Irons and Sun Tzu quotes are quoted by Sandy there and in Chapter 6, The Undivided Self.
Sandy Dunlop wrote The Golfing Bodymind in 1980 and has coached golfers at every level since.
To **stop overthinking your golf swing**, shift your focus from conscious control to developing integrated, habitual movement patterns. Adopt a **systems thinking approach** that incorporates techniqu...
21 min readThe golf putting yips are not a character flaw, a sign of weakness, or evidence that you've somehow forgotten how to putt. They are a nervous system event — a deeply patterned protective response wher...
19 min readThe yips are not a technique failure. They are a nervous system event — a freeze response triggered by the autonomic nervous system when the brain perceives a threat that doesn't actually exist. If yo...
18 min readEvery golfer who overthinks knows the frustration: you sense something is wrong in your swing, you try to fix it, and things get worse. The path to an effortless golf swing is not what you expect — it...
17 min readA golf mental reset isn't just a nice idea. It's a neurological necessity. When a bad shot cascades into a worse one, something very specific happens in your bodymind... your breathing shortens, your ...
15 min readMost golfers obsess over birdies. I want to talk about something arguably more important, especially for mid-to-high handicappers: your ability to minimise the damage when things start to go wrong. Th...
17 min readA psychosynthesis technique for getting distance from a part of yourself that has taken over. You name it and then separate from it in the same breath: I am a perfectionist, and I am not my perfectionist. That small distance, sometimes described as being on the balcony, is where choice becomes possible again.
Not in itself. The Perfectionist is the drive to improve, to put in the hours and to reach for mastery, and plenty of good golf comes from it. It turns costly when it becomes an intense punitive voice that takes the joy out of the game, which Shivas Irons called the quicksands of perfection.
Not by silencing it, because honest feedback on performance is useful. Name it instead, accept what it is for, and dis-identify from it so that it is one voice rather than the whole of you. Then work on where it is in conflict with the other parts of you, which is usually where a round comes apart.
Work out which of the six reasons you actually play for. Most golfers who lose heart have been measuring themselves against somebody else's why.
The question has a false premise. You are one system, not a body plus a percentage. Here is where the split came from and what changes when you drop it.
Answer a few questions and Sandy builds a plan around the rounds you actually play, covering practice, mind, body and food. Free, and no card.