
Find out which of the six reasons you actually play for, because you have probably been chasing somebody else's. Sandy takes the six from the dinner party in Golf in the Kingdom: performance, enjoyment, learning, challenge, friendship and the spiritual. None of them is the right one. A golfer whose real why is the walk and the weather, grinding away at a scoring target, will lose heart every single time.
Answered by Sandy Dunlop, author of The Golfing Bodymind, drawing on the Golfing Bodymind method.
In Michael Murphy's Golf in the Kingdom there is a dinner after a day on the links at Burning Bush, and over the evening each guest says something different about why they play. Sandy uses that table as the standard set, because between them they cover almost everyone.
Evan Tyree, the champion, is performance: delivering against the best when it actually matters. Agatha McNaughton is enjoyment, and she puts it better than any coach would, as smelling the heather and the cut grass, walking fast across the countryside and feeling the wind. Peter McNaughton is learning, and for him the game is an x-ray of the soul. Peter is also challenge, comparing golf to a marriage, needing steadiness of purpose and imagination, strength and deft touch, steady nerves and a wild streak. Agatha names friendship, which she describes as the way men have found to be together and still keep a proper distance. And Adam Green brings the spiritual, calling golf a yoga of the super mind and a discipline of transcendence.
Systems thinking has a useful word for this. Equifinality means the same end can be reached by a variety of different paths. None of the six stories at that table was told as the right way to play. Each was a personal reflection on what gets somebody out of the house on a cold February day.
Which means the job is not to adopt a better motivation. It is to identify the one that is already yours and stop apologising for it.
Sandy's argument for taking this seriously is structural rather than sentimental. One of the jobs of the prefrontal cortex is storytelling: out of the cacophony of signals arriving from everywhere in the body it has to assemble one unifying story that makes sense of things. That story is what explains the why, and the why is the energising mechanism that the rest of the system organises itself around.
Without it, he says, you have a car with no engine. All the technique in the world sits there, correct and unused.
Write down which of the six is genuinely yours on a wet day in February, not which one sounds most serious. Then look at what you have been working on lately and ask whether it serves that one.
A golfer who plays for friendship and enjoyment, who has spent six months grinding a swing change alone on a range, has not lost motivation. They have been doing somebody else's golf. The fix is not more discipline.
Sandy asks golfers to do something before they commit to any real change: listen to both voices honestly. The yes voice is the excitement, the hope, the possibility of being better than you thought you could be. The no voice is the memory of having tried before, several times, and the fear of how sharp the disappointment will be if this one also comes to nothing.
The no voice is not weakness and it is not wrong. It is usually accurate about the past. Naming it out loud is what stops it from quietly running the decision, and once the decision is genuinely made, he reckons the resources and the guides tend to turn up.
The six motivations, the storytelling role of the prefrontal cortex, the car with no engine and equifinality are from Chapter 7 of The Golfing Bodymind, Motivation Matters. The quoted lines belong to Michael Murphy's characters in Golf in the Kingdom, which Sandy draws on throughout. The yes voice and no voice are from Chapter 1.
Sandy Dunlop wrote The Golfing Bodymind in 1980 and has coached golfers at every level since.
You've got a round coming up and you're already dreading it. Your game hasn't been sharp, life has been relentless, and somewhere in the back of your mind a quiet voice is already writing the disaster...
15 min readStories are not decoration. In my experience, they are one of the most powerful transmission systems human beings have ever invented for getting wisdom from one person to another. That is exactly why ...
16 min readGolf consistency isn't something you find by scrolling through tips on social media. I know, because I've tried that approach, and it simply doesn't work. What I'm talking about is something deeper: t...
18 min readMost golfers don't improve because they collect tips with no framework to organise them. I've seen this for decades. A golfer reads a magazine, watches a YouTube video, gets a nugget from a playing pa...
19 min readOften because what you are working on has drifted away from the reason you actually play. Sandy uses six motivations: performance, enjoyment, learning, challenge, friendship and the spiritual. If your real why is the company and the countryside, and your golf has become a solitary scoring project, losing heart is the predictable result rather than a failing.
Performance, enjoyment, learning, challenge, friendship and the spiritual. Sandy takes them from the dinner party scene in Michael Murphy's Golf in the Kingdom, where each guest gave a different reason for loving the game, and he treats all six as equally valid.
It is extremely common, and Sandy builds it into the method rather than treating it as a problem. He asks golfers to listen to the no voice, the one that remembers trying before and dreads another disappointment, because naming it honestly is what stops it from making the decision for you.
Because a part of you has taken the whole of you over. The sub personalities, what each one is for, and the one sentence that gets you back on the balcony.
Yes, and it was never aimed at tour players. The promise is you surprising you. What is the same at every handicap, and what is different if yours is high.
Answer a few questions and Sandy builds a plan around the rounds you actually play, covering practice, mind, body and food. Free, and no card.